Sherpa Bear Hat vs. Navy Pom Hat: Which Baby Hat to Pick
By SpearmintLOVE | Baby Shop | Timeless Baby Essentials | Published: 2026-11-03
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Sherpa Bear Hat and Navy Pom Hat on sizing, warmth, and care to choose the right baby winter hat for your newborn or growing baby.
Quick answer
Choose the Baby's First Hat, Navy Pom for a newborn's first days and hospital bag, because it is a one-size newborn hat with a soft, stretchy fit. Choose the Sherpa Bear Hat, Teddy for an adjustable, baseball-style hat that can fit a growing baby across sizes.
Sizing: fixed newborn vs. adjustable fit
The Navy Pom Hat comes in only one size: newborn. That makes it a straightforward choice for the earliest weeks, but it will not grow with your baby. The Sherpa Bear Hat is an adjustable baseball-style hat offered in multiple sizes, so you can choose a size that matches your baby's head and adjust the fit as needed. If you are shopping before birth and want a hat that works for the hospital and coming-home outfit, the Navy Pom is the simpler pick. If you want a hat that can be worn over several months, the Sherpa Bear's size options and adjustable closure give you more room to work with.
Warmth and material: what each hat is made of
Both hats are made of 100% polyester. The Navy Pom Hat is described as soft and stretchy, which suits a newborn's head and helps the hat stay on without being tight. The Sherpa Bear Hat is a baseball-style cap with an adjustable back, so its warmth comes from full head coverage rather than a stretchy pull-on fit. Neither hat is described as waterproof or as a heavy winter hat, so treat both as everyday warm baby hats rather than extreme-cold gear. If you need a hat for deep winter, layer with a hood or choose a heavier style; if you need a hat for mild cold, either works.
Care and longevity
The Navy Pom Hat requires hand washing in cold water and laying flat to dry. The Sherpa Bear Hat also recommends hand washing, but should be hung to dry and must not be bleached or dry cleaned. Both need gentle care, so neither is a toss-in-the-machine hat. The bigger difference is lifespan: the Navy Pom is a newborn-only hat, while the Sherpa Bear Hat's size range means it can serve older babies. If you want one hat to last through several seasons, the Sherpa Bear Hat is the more flexible choice; if you want a dedicated first hat, the Navy Pom is purpose-built for that stage.
Key trade-offs
- Fit and sizing: Navy Pom is newborn-only and stretchy; Sherpa Bear is adjustable and available in sizes. Pick Navy Pom for a true newborn fit; pick Sherpa Bear if you want a hat that adjusts as your baby grows. If you are buying before birth, the Navy Pom is the safer first hat; if you are buying for a baby older than a few weeks, start with the Sherpa Bear.
- Warmth and style: Both are 100% polyester. Navy Pom is a soft, stretchy pull-on with a pom; Sherpa Bear is a baseball-style cap with an adjustable back. Neither is a heavy winter hat, so choose based on whether you want a classic newborn look or an adjustable cap. For mild cold, either works; for deep winter, plan to layer or choose a heavier hat.
- Care and lifespan: Navy Pom: hand wash cold, lay flat to dry. Sherpa Bear: hand wash, hang dry, no bleach or dry cleaning. Navy Pom lasts only the newborn stage; Sherpa Bear can last through multiple sizes. If you want one hat to last beyond the newborn stage, the Sherpa Bear is the more practical choice.
Product facts
- Baby's First Hat®, Navy Pom: One size only: newborn; 100% polyester; hand wash cold, lay flat to dry. This hat is designed for the first weeks, so it will not fit older babies, but it is a simple hospital-bag staple.
Baby's First Hat®, Navy Pom - Sherpa Bear Hat, Teddy: Adjustable baseball-style hat; 100% polyester; hand wash recommended, hang dry, do not bleach or dry clean. The adjustable fit and size options let you dial in a secure fit as your baby grows, and the care routine is straightforward but gentle.
Sherpa Bear Hat, Teddy
Which hat is right for you?
Best for
- Parents packing a hospital bag or bringing a newborn home
- Buyers who want a simple, soft first hat for a baby in the first weeks
Not for
- Babies older than the newborn stage or parents who want a hat that adjusts as the baby grows
- Anyone looking for a heavy winter hat for extreme cold
